Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Anbuchelvans and chelvis.. we need u !

**this is a true life incident.Characters and places in this blog are very much real.


A recent experience my friends and I had while traveling in a popular weekend train made me realize… the sorry state of affairs that our country operates in. It just somehow runs .

My friend lost her purse containing a bit of cash and a lot of cards – atm cards, corporate travel cards, credit cards during our train journey – it accidentally fell out of the train- and my two friends and I decided to place a complaint in the Police Station just so that we have a complaint number to block any of the cards, we weren’t anyway expecting them to find her purse – that would be too much of an ask.

Three girls enter the police station at the wee hours of the morning: there’s a lady cop sitting in one of the rooms and two constables – it’s a dungeon like damp smelling dimly lit place. This is what transpired there.

“enna ma enna venum”What do u want??

“ sir, purse a misplace pannitom train la – it has some money and a few cards - we need to place a complaint”.

“oh!!! where did u lose it” I was skeptical about the excitement! Enna da ivlo aarvama ?

“in transit sir..it fell out of the train accidentally”

“ Ange tholachitu inge vandhu keetenna naanga inna pannamudiyum?” pat came the reply.Just as I thought! The eagerness is to pass the buck! Not my business!u dint lose it here y ask me!

“What do we do sir? Train just came here.. so we got down to complain… “ A stress on the “sir” a little bit at least ensured we dint hear bad vocabulary.

He goes on” You should have stopped the train then and there.. got down and searched for the purse !” Is he crazy!?? I think.. Does he really expect anybody to get out of a train at 2 in the night in a godforsaken place in utter darkness and search for a purse?



What followed was like the lecture the station master gives to Kareena in Jab we met. Advice… on how IT people don’t realize the value of hard earned money As if my company pours dollars on me for sitting and writing stories in offical time! …on how we will easily get the new cards back and never realize the pain of losing something.. I half-listen half think whether I should also ask him like Kareena did –“ do u give this advice in free or do u charge something for this also.. “…

And then he said something which I just couldn digest… in this era of teracomputing! – He says “ ok.. for your satisfaction place your complaint… But how will it reach jolarpet!!!! U should have got down complained to the station master there! If you complain here what can I do??God .. this guy was totally in the wrong era.. anachronic is the word.. “mail .. call ..fax..courier.... its ur business to take the complaint to jolarpet .. not mine” I was thinking.. And I was appalled at our police force not even being aware of basic technologies… I looked around… not a single computer in sight.. just some wooden tables, chairs, tattered files –all belonging to the pre –independence era I’m sure and this guy in front of me.. who also probably is from there.These people are so technologically backward – anyone can give them the slip!

The complaint was written in a piece of recycled – pale yellow paper- no number , no file - with a ball point pen that kept stopping – bah! That’ll go straight into the trash I thought as my friend wrote a letter.. this guy giving hundred instructions on the format of the letter.. whom it should be addressed to etc , rather than bothering about whether it had details of what got lost and whats the contact number of the person who placed the complaint! .. Finally we were done and this fellow says- “ Don’t expect us to find your purse. In case some guy with a good heart finds it, he ll take the money and send you the cards don’t worry.” Pakka..
Attitude,,unne maadiri naalu peru irundha naadu uruppadum I thought..

As this was happening the lady cop was asking us unnecessary details irrelevant to that situation – IT course better a computer science better a.. endha college.. endha course.. “friends llarum ore edathula place aana jolly a irkum la.. “ Romba mukhiyam ippo.. kaarthala 5 manikku police station ku ungala paathutu naalu vaartha kadha pesitu polamnu daan vandhen..… How can she master the art of talking the irrelevant! ,.. I was fuming… .

As this was happening.. a lady was bought to the station by her relative.. she was wailing.. and why wont she !She had lost her daughter there!! And the first thing that a wailing .. perturbed mother gets when she rushes to the police station to complain that her daughter is missing… “Arivu ille unakku??? .. Ipdi daan ishatathuku poga viduviya” that lady cop asks!! Ariville unakku… neenum oru lady thane.. yaaravadhu venumne ponna tholaipangala?? To rub salt to the wounds.. when the cop learns of the girl’s age being 14 .. she starts off.. “vayasu pullaya poi tholachitiye.. enna vena aagalam….” I was standing there..shocked at the treatement being meted out to a lady who is already in the trauma of losing her child… is this the way you talk to her?? “Summa edhayaadhu tholachitu complaint vandhu kudukkavendiyadhu.. engalukullam vera vela ille??” Shock! Vera enna vela irku unakku… this is ur primary job!!! That too in a railway station where hundreds of people come and go everyday.. things are bound to get lost.. and that’s the only reason you are here!

Then a few more questions on where they lost her, when, etc. all just for formality- neither did that female note down the details nor did it register even in the remotest corner of her head. Inspite of all the arrogance and callousness I had witnessed since morning the little bit of optimism that still remained in me decided to wait and see…what happens… I expected at least a couple of constables to go with the mother.. aid her in her search… a few announcements on the microphone… lets see.. I waited..

To my utter shock and disbelief.. not one soul budged from that police station.. a person is lost.. a young girl at that..no search team formed.. not even an announcement on the mike. No one willing to listen to the details of what she was wearing..did she carry money… they dint even ask her name!!!! and the only reaction the police gives is.. “complaint kuduthutu po.. paaklam… “ A similar piece of pale yellow paper comes out.. and in all her anxiety and turmoil.. the mother wastes her time filling up a sheet of paper..which is going to go to the trash.. From their “initial investigation” the police made an “important breakthrough” ..the girl can read and write … “ Seri seri She can read and write ah.. she ll find her way herself..”.. Wow.. this is what the police is there for… to tell me that she will find her way back herself..!Idhu enakku theriyadha

I was left wondering.. the treatment meted out to my friend s purse and the lady’s daughter… was the same! Give your complaint and go.. if they find their way back.. u are lucky! Sheer arrogance, lack of involvement in the work they do, zero use of technology, zero accountability, untrained on how to handle people, laziness.. endless list of “areas to improve”. Idhu ipdi than irkuma? Is there no way to improve this? Can I do something? Atleast let me begin by writing this to express my anger and anguish.

What we need is a complete revamp of our police stations.. Computers! For heaven’s sake!! And a bunch of young ones.. willing to do the job.. throw out the manual work.. replace them wih computers.. throw out 10 old unwilling arrogant monsters and replace them with 5 youngs turks who like the job they do.. and you can pay them well enough to lure more youngsters to the police force.

Anbuchelvans & chelvis! We need u…







12 comments:

Shiva said...

U should have got down complained to the station master there! If you complain here what can I do??God .. this guy was totally in the wrong era.. anachronic is the word.. “mail .. call ..fax..courier.... its ur business to take the complaint to jolarpet .. not mine”

This sums up your frustration and our police system! Good use of italics...

Maithreyi said...

Wow.. Great start.. What can't the youngsters do ?.. CNN has started the students blog.. You can put the post there.What a pathetic situation!This post has to directly go to the DGP's desk n that police station has to be fired.. Thats the start.. Wonderful post..I share your agony n anguish.. Abdul Kalam's dream "INDIA 2020".. Gandhiji's dream.. And every other leader dreams.. only dreams.. All futile...Even in the next few million yrs India will go nowhere.. My blood boils as I read the post..How can ppl be so careless..? World Arise.. Awake and stop not..

Sandhya said...

Every young indian reading this blog will be distressed Swe..U've done a good job posting this :).A really good piece of writing . 'What can we do?' is the question here .. And the answer i guess is a meek 'i dont know'. How do we change the attitude of half the nation that is this way?

Nagesh said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Nagesh said...

good blog, atlast u understood the arrogance,bureaucracy and finally last your temper :)but what else u can do ? just u can express your anger over blog and we atmost can read the blog ! Only thoughts nothing become realty :)

Srinivasan said...

Okay Y am i feeling like defending the system. I am not sure :D
Bt the post is very cynical, frivolous and superficial
(I am a harsh critic)
Certain hitches:
1. You could deactivate the card by furnishing personal details with the bank rather than haranguing with cops
2. Law and order is still maintained in India in spite of your calls of anarchy
3. What you sow is what you reap!!
If you would be willing to cuff up and become a cop, and may be convince your friends, things can become better
Everything works in cycles. The best talent is attracted naturally where pay is more. So when the cops get paid more, which btw can happen only when crime reaches top of the agenda, will talented people be attracted to the police force.
(Nd for godsake, above(maithreyi) who wants to fire a station. Seems like straight outta movie)
No offence!!

Anonymous said...

They are a bunch of " " " " and you can't expect anything to be done with them. The best solution is keep your things safe! My strong feeling is that these things can never change, no matter what we do to change them.

Here is an exactly opposite situation.I remember an episode of "Beach Patrol" where a guy calls up 911 to complain that somebody stole his "towel" from the public laundry facility. An officer arrives at the scene and takes the complaint about the color,size and other description of the towel. The cop then passes the message over the phone to other cops to watch out for people using a "white towel" along the beach, stop them for enquiry.
This is a real incident.

AJ said...

hey!! well said...talks a lot about our system! didnt really get the title tho..

cheers,
Aparna Jeyaraman

Murali said...

Come on Swetha...set the example... quit intel. Crack the indian civil service examination... become an IAS or IPS officer and change the system... what say ? :)

I don't know who he is, but i PERFECTLY agree with Mr Srinivasan here.

It's so easy to lambast the cops. I perfectly understand the ordeal u n ur frnds have been thru. I've been in one such situation - sitting in a police station of a state whose local language I had no clue of, desperately trying to negotiate a 500 rs bribe down to a cheaper amt.

Thats the way it is yaar. When a so-called well educated person like you or me didn't bother to enter the political or bureaucratic system and clean it up, why expect someone else to do it?

Why ask for other anbuchelvans or chelvis... become one yourself... set the example !

Murali said...

a request...

if after reading my prev comment, u now wanna say - "Moron murali, don't ya dare read ma blog again", kindly do tat personally n not publicly here :D

:)

Kartik said...

Interesting blog... I would agree with srinivasan here... Deactivate your card before someone finds it...

Being a girl who can read and write I guess thats the first thing you should have done... I have been robbed off 300 Dollars.. So i now know what I should be doing when I lose my wallet :)

I know this is way out of place, but maybe the police were using recycled paper ;)

And again, the way they treat ppl is not really justified, but I will agree that for the country and the population, they are not that bad after all!!

PS:: This just shows you are watching a lot of movies and the tamil serials..

An$ar Za!nul said...

Good to see some more people venting out their frustration on our sorry state of affairs through sensible blogging evryday...
This goes a long way in bringing such issues in the public domain and getting more people of our generation pondering over it.. its perhaps the slowest but certainly the surest way to bring about a change in our social consciousness!